CLEVELAND, Ohio — In a game the Guardians would rather forget, Nolan Jones provided the lone highlight — a three-run home run that might just signal the start of something special. The Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast zeroed in on this silver lining from Sunday’s otherwise forgettable 13-3 loss to the Boston Red Sox, suggesting Jones’ breakthrough could be far more significant than it initially appeared.
“That was the first time Nolan Jones ever hit a home run in Progressive Field. So, that’s a step in the right direction,” noted podcast host Joe Noga, highlighting just how meaningful this particular blast was for Jones.
The home run wasn’t just Jones’ first at Progressive Field — it was his first in 189 at-bats dating back to last season and represented what could be the start of results finally matching his impressive underlying metrics. While his batting average sits at a disappointing .191, a peek “under the hood” reveals a player who’s been making quality contact without the corresponding results.
“He’s hitting .191, but his hard hit percentage and his exit velocity are top 100 percentile in all of baseball. But his batting average on balls in play, it only ranks like 52nd among major league outfielders,” Noga explained, diving into the analytics that suggest Jones has been hitting into significant bad luck.
This statistical disconnect — elite hard-hit metrics paired with mediocre results — points to an impending correction. As Noga put it: “The two numbers mean he’s, he’s hitting into bad luck. He’s barreling up the ball, hitting line drives and either guys are making nice catches or he’s hitting them right at people.”
The podcast discussion mirrors what Guardians manager Stephen Vogt has been saying about Jones. After a recent game against Pittsburgh where Jones crushed multiple balls with nothing to show for it, Vogt predicted a breakout was imminent. Sunday’s home run may have been the first tangible evidence of that prediction coming true.
“It looks like Vogt’s prediction that he’s on his way to a breakout is ringing accurate,” Noga observed.
For players stuck in statistical anomalies like Jones, sometimes all it takes is one big hit to open the floodgates. Baseball history is filled with hitters who struggled for weeks only to see everything click after one meaningful connection. That Sunday blast could be precisely that catalyst for Jones.
More Guardians coverage
How to watch the Guardians: See how to watch Guardians games with this handy game-by-game TV schedule.
Paul Hoynes noted that Jones certainly passes the eye test for a power hitter: “He’s a big guy,” Hoynes said. “He looks like he should generate some power.” Those physical tools, combined with his advanced metrics, paint the picture of a player on the verge.
The concept of “batting average on balls in play” (BABIP) discussed on the podcast is particularly relevant to Jones’ situation. League average typically hovers around .300-.315, with numbers significantly lower often indicating a player hitting into unusually bad luck. When those numbers inevitably correct toward the mean, the results can be dramatic.
As Cleveland enters a crucial series against division rival Minnesota, Jones’ homer could represent more than just three runs in a losing effort — it might be the moment he turned the corner. For a Guardians team that has sometimes struggled to generate consistent power, unlocking Jones’ full potential would add a valuable dimension to their offense.
Sometimes baseball rewards persistence. After weeks of crushing balls with nothing to show for it, Jones may have finally gotten the monkey off his back. If the metrics hold true, this could be just the beginning of his impact in Cleveland.
If the player above doesn’t work, you can listen to the podcast here.
Note: Artificial intelligence was used to help generate this story from the Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast by cleveland.com. Visitors to cleveland.com have asked for more text stories based on website podcast discussions.